{"id":12523,"date":"2025-08-02T09:30:07","date_gmt":"2025-08-02T07:30:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/?p=12523"},"modified":"2026-11-21T19:31:40","modified_gmt":"2026-11-21T17:31:40","slug":"commentary-on-the-madhyamakavatara-part-1-collection-of-reasoning%ef%bb%bf","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/?p=12523","title":{"rendered":"Commentary on the Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra\u2014Part 1\u2014Collection of Reasoning\ufeff"},"content":{"rendered":"<div id=\"attachment_12524\" style=\"width: 226px\" class=\"wp-caption alignleft\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/08\/khenpo_namdrol_tsering.jpg\"><img aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-12524\" loading=\"lazy\" class=\"size-medium wp-image-12524\" src=\"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/08\/khenpo_namdrol_tsering-216x300.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"216\" height=\"300\" srcset=\"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/08\/khenpo_namdrol_tsering-216x300.jpg 216w, https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/08\/khenpo_namdrol_tsering.jpg 240w\" sizes=\"(max-width: 216px) 100vw, 216px\" \/><\/a><p id=\"caption-attachment-12524\" class=\"wp-caption-text\"><span style=\"color: #993300;\">Khenpo Namdrol Tsering<\/span><\/p><\/div>\n<p align=\"left\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\"><b>Commentary on the Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra\u2014Part 1\u2014Collection of Reasoning<\/b><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\"><i>by\u00a0<a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/\">Khenchen Namdrol Tsering<\/a><\/i><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">In this teaching, translated from an audio recording, Khenchen Namdrol Tsering explains the background to Candrak\u012brti&#8217;s classic work by discussing the texts of the &#8216;collection (or corpus) of reasoning&#8217; (<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">rigs tshogs<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">) attributed to N\u0101g\u0101rjuna, the great philosopher and founder of the Madhyamaka tradition.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/p>\n<h2 class=\"western\" align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra: Collection of Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/h2>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">by Khenchen Namdrol Rinpoche<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<h3 class=\"western\" align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">Motivation<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/h3>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Please listen to this explanation with the supreme motivation of\u00a0<u>bodhicitta<\/u>, wishing to attain perfect awakening for the sake of all sentient beings.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<h3 class=\"western\" align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\">Introduction to the Text<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/h3>\n<h4 class=\"western\" align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The Collection of\u00a0<u>Middle Way<\/u>\u00a0Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/h4>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The great master\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>\u0100rya<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0was prophesied by the Buddha himself in the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Tantra<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Ma\u00f1ju\u015br\u012b<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(Ma\u00f1ju\u015br\u012bm\u016bla Tantra)<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Four hundred years after I,<br \/>\nThe\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Tath\u0101gata<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, have passed away,<br \/>\nA monk called N\u0101ga will appear<br \/>\nWho will benefit my teachings.<br \/>\nReaching the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>bh\u016bmi<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0of Perfect Joy<br \/>\nAnd living for six hundred years,<br \/>\nThis great being will perfect<br \/>\nThe science of the great peacock,<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:1\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[1]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\nAnd will understand the meaning of various \u015b\u0101stras<br \/>\nAnd the meaning of the absence of reality.<br \/>\nWhen he leaves behind his mortal body,<br \/>\nHe will be reborn in\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Sukh\u0101vat\u012b<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<br \/>\nAnd ultimately, he will certainly gain<br \/>\nhe perfect fruit of buddhahood itself.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p><!--more--><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">He was also prophesied in the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Great Cloud\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>S\u016btra<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(Mah\u0101megha-s\u016btra)<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">S\u016btra of the Great Drum (Mah\u0101bher\u012bh\u0101rakaparivarta-s\u016btra)<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u0100rya N\u0101g\u0101rjuna&#8217;s two main treatises\u2014the so-called \u2018body\u2019 treatises\u2014are\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the Middle Way (M\u016blamadhyamakak\u0101rik\u0101)<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. The text we are concerned with here is the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Introduction to the Middle Way<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">) by Candrakirti, which is a commentary on the meaning of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Generally speaking, N\u0101g\u0101rjuna composed treatises on all five sciences. Those on the science of the inner meaning, i.e., the Buddhadharma, primarily teach the aspects of view and conduct. In describing the view and the conduct of the Dharma,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0employs both scriptural quotations and reasoning. The treatise that mostly uses quotations from the scriptures is the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Compendium of S\u016btras (S\u016btrasamuccaya)<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. It draws from the sutras in order to explain and clarify the aspects of view and conduct.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">There are three collections that mainly employ reasoning in order to clarify the view and the conduct of the buddhist teachings. They are the Collection of Reasoning, the Collection of Praises and the Collection of Advice.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The Collection of Praises relates mainly to the final turning of the Wheel of Dharma. It includes eulogies in praise of the ground, the path and the fruition.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:2\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:3\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The Collection of Advice relates mainly to the first turning. It includes the advice to the king known as the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:2\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[2]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0as well as the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Letter to a Friend<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:3\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[3]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:4\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:5\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">According to some past scholars the Collection of Reasoning was originally referred to simply as \u2018the collection\u2019 or \u2018the teachings\u2019 of logical reasoning and the number of texts it contained was not specified. Others, such as Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:4\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[4]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and the omniscient Gowo Rabjampa,<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:5\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[5]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0insist that the Collection of Reasoning contains a specific number of texts. They differ in the texts they identify; yet they agree on the principle that the number of texts in the collection is fixed.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:6\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:7\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:8\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:9\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc said that the Collection of Reasoning contains six texts. Among these, he said, two texts are likened to the body, and this is clear because it is stated so in Candrak\u012brti\u2019s commentary to\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. The two body-like texts are\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. In addition, Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc goes on, there are four branch or limb-like treatises. He claims that this derives from Candrak\u012brti\u2019s\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Commentary to the Sixty Verses on Reasoning,<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0where it is explained how these four texts are elaborations upon the two fundamental treatises. However, this text only describes\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:6\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[6]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Stanzas on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:7\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[7]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0as extensions of the main two treatises. It does not mention\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:8\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[8]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0or\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence,<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:9\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[9]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0which are the other texts Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc includes among the collection.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Gorampa disagrees with Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc because of this very point. It is clear, he says, that\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Verses on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0are branch-like treatises, because the way in which they are extensions of the main two treatises is clearly explained. As for\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Gorampa believes that it too may be counted as a branch-like treatise, and in this it seems he is in agreement with many past scholars. He also agrees that the main topic of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is the refutation of the so-called \u2018sixteen topics (Skt.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">pad\u0101rtha<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">) of the dialecticians.\u2019 As the text itself says:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><a name=\"fnref:10\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">With the pride of intellectual knowledge,<br \/>\nThey seek to engage in debate.<br \/>\nIn order that they might relinquish such pride,<br \/>\nI shall explain the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:10\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[10]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">So,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to a Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is included among the branch-like treatises.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc includes\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0among the branch-like treatises. This is because the teachings of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0on how all phenomena are naturally beyond arising and empty might cause one to doubt whether all phenomena are non-existent even at the conventional level, rather like the horns of a rabbit or the horns of a donkey. Therefore\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0was taught, it is said, in order to dispel this misunderstanding, and to show how at the conventional level all phenomena are illusory and dream-like. So Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc claims that there are six texts in the Collection of Reasoning, and that one of them is\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The Omniscient\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Longchenpa<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0also states that there are six texts in the Collection of Reasoning, the sixth being\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:11\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Gorampa disputes the inclusion of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. In the first place, he objects to this on the grounds that it was not translated into Tibetan. He goes on to say that it probably did not exist even in India because Candrak\u012brti fails to mention it at the end of his\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Clear Words<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:11\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[11]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0commentary upon the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the Middle Way<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0when listing all the Madhyamaka texts that he had studied. If\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0really was the work of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Gorampa argues, then Candrak\u012brti would certainly have studied it. This is the relevant section of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Clear Words<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><a name=\"fnref:12\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">What I have shown here is based on my study of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Compendium of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>S\u016btras<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Advice of the Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">In Praise of the Authentic<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, and also, for a long time and with great effort, the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">K\u0101rik\u0101s<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0from the treatise of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>\u0100rya<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0[N\u0101g\u0101rjuna] , and the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning, Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Stanzas on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0as well as\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0too. I also looked into the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[Four] Hundred Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and so on, and many profound sutras, as well as the commentary composed by Buddhap\u0101lita and that which was well explained by Bh\u0101vaviveka\u2014all these texts one after another\u2014and I have also included what I have discovered through my own investigations, bringing everything together in order to delight all those with intelligence.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:12\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[12]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">It is because it is not among the works listed here that Gorampa felt\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0was unknown in India.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:13\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">As stated earlier, Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc was amongst those earlier scholars who believed that\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0should be included in the Collection of Reasoning. Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc\u2019s main teacher was\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Lotsawa<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0Patsab Nyima Drakpa<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:13\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[13]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0who actually translated the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Introduction to the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0from Sanskrit into Tibetan, as the translator\u2019s colophon at the end of the text says:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\">\u2026<span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">by the Indian abbot Tilaka Kalasha and the Tibetan translator, the monk Patsab Nyima Drak\u2026.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:14\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">And, what is more, Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc was not just an average student; he was one of the four great disciples of Patsab Nyima Drakpa, the so-called \u2018four sons\u2019 of Patsab , i.e., Geshe Putowa from Central Tibet, Sokpa Yeshe Jungne from Changthang, and Tsangpa Sarb\u00f6 and Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc from Tsang.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:14\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[14]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">So it seems strange that one of the principal students of this great Tibetan translator who worked in collaboration with an Indian scholar to translate Candrak\u012brti\u2019s text would consider a non-existent text to exist, and, not only that, but also for it to be the work of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, and to be included within his Collection of Reasoning. If there were a reason to doubt the existence of the text in India or its authorship, Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc would surely have been aware of it. There is no obvious reason why he would endorse a spurious text, or its subject matter, or why he might wish to see it included in the Collection of Reasoning.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Lotsawa<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0Patsab Nyima Drakpa was one of the great translators and Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc was his direct disciple. They would certainly have known whether or not there was a text by\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>\u0100rya<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0N\u0101g\u0101rjuna called\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. And they would certainly not have attributed existence to such a text if there were no grounds for doing so. This must be our conclusion too, if we investigate the matter. Hence, Gyalse Shenpen Taye, the Omniscient\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Longchenpa<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and others include\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Conventional Existence<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0in the Collection of Reasoning and the reasons for its exclusion provided by Gorampa may be considered insufficient.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:15\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:16\"><\/a><a name=\"fnref:17\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">The\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Treasury of Secret Mantra Scripture<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:15\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[15]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is a text belonging to the category of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>terma<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0related to the cycle of Deshek D\u00fcpa, and it includes statements by\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Vimalamitra<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Guru Rinpoche, Namkhe Nyingpo and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Vairotsana<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. This text also refers to a sixfold Collection of Reasoning, but it gives the sixth text as\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:16\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[16]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0According to Indian scholars and the earlier Tibetan commentators\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear_is a work of \u0100rya\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. Nevertheless, it is a commentary on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, and therefore differs from the other body-lilke or branch-like treatises of the collection. All the same, earlier scholars considered it an \u2018auto-commentary\u2019 to the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses_composed by N\u0101g\u0101rjuna himself. More recently however, Gorampa and others have expressed doubts about this, primarily because the text includes a citation from \u0100ryadeva\u2019s\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Four Hundred Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:17\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[17]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0\u0100ryadeva was N\u0101g\u0101rjuna\u2019s pupil, and it seems unlikely that in commenting upon a text that he himself had written, N\u0101g\u0101rjuna would quote his own student. So there are those who doubt the attribution of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0to N\u0101g\u0101rjuna.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Gorampa and others who have questioned its attribution to N\u0101g\u0101rjuna have also expressed further misgivings about\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. Why, they ask, would Candrak\u012brti have composed his\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Clear Words<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0commentary to the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0if N\u0101g\u0101rjuna himself had already composed an auto-commentary? And, furthermore, why is it that there are no quotations drawn from\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0in the writings of Buddhap\u0101lita? The answer can only be, Gorampa and the others claim, that the text in question is not in fact a genuine work of N\u0101g\u0101rjuna.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Whether or not N\u0101g\u0101rjuna wrote\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, it is perhaps best not to include it in the Collection of Reasoning. It is preferable to classify it as a commentary on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. If all the commentaries composed by\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0were to be included in the Collection of Reasoning we would have to include his commentary on\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and other texts and we might end up with something more like an\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">eight<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">fold collection!<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">There are eight commentaries on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0in the Tengyur, one of which is\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. There are also those by Deva\u015barma, Gu\u1e47amati, Gu\u1e47a\u015br\u012b, Sthiramati, Buddhap\u0101lita, Bh\u0101vaviveka and Candrak\u012brti. Although there is some controversy over whether or not\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Beyond All Fear<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is an auto-commentary (i.e. by N\u0101g\u0101rjuna himself), the fact that it is a commentary is beyond dispute. And according to the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Treasury of Secret Mantra Quotations<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0it is one of the six treatises in the Collection of Reasoning.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:18\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">According to Gorampa, there are only five texts in the Collection of Reasoning.<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:18\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[18]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0Among these, the two likened to the body are\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. Although they are both body-like texts we can draw a distinction between the two. Some past scholars explained that the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0teach a freedom from the eight extremes of elaboration, i.e., ceasing and arising, non-existence and eternalism, coming and going, multiplicity and singularity, whereas the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0teaches a freedom from four extremes, i.e., arising, ceasing, existence and non-existence. Others have explained that the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0refute the assertions of true existence made by both Buddhist proponents of true entities and non-Buddhist\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>t\u012brthika<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0philosophers; whereas the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0refutes only the assertions of true existence made by proponents of entities within the Buddhist tradition. Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc explained the difference between the two texts in the following way. He said that the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0teaches emptiness of inherent nature by means of elimination and negation; whereas the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0teaches emptiness of inherent nature by exclusively establishing the illusory nature of the conventional.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">In any case, these are the two \u2018body-like treatises\u2019 and the so-called \u2018branch-like treatises\u2019 extend from these.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">According to Gorampa, the first \u2018branch-like treatise\u2019 is the \u2018treatise refuting the views imputed by others\u2019. The \u2018views imputed by others\u2019 are the sixteen categories of words and meanings of the dialecticians, and the treatise that refutes these is\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Crushing to Fine Powder<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:19\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">According to our own tradition, once again the two body-like treatises are the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses on the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Sixty Verses on Reasoning<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">. Then, among the branch-like treatises,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is said to be an expansion of the first section of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0on \u2018Examining Conditions\u2019. The\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0teaches how there can be no arising of something from itself or from something other than itself, and therefore brings certainty in the non-arising of all phenomena. The proponents of entities respond by saying that if this were the case, then even M\u0101dhyamika reasoning is without true nature. And since this reasoning is without true nature then it is not able to refute the claims made in favour of true existence. It is therefore unreasonable, they say, to claim that all phenomena are ultimately beyond arising, or beyond the two extremes of eternalism and nihilism. It is said that\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0was composed in order to refute such arguments. In the text, it is stated that from the point of view of reality itself, the M\u0101dhyamikas have nothing to refute, and have no reasoning by which they might do so. From the conventional perspective however, even though reasoning is not truly existent, the M\u0101dhyamikas are still able to refute the assertions made by the proponents of entities, rather like a magically-created, illusory army warding off attack. For example, in the first verse of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, it is said:<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:19\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[19]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">If all entities are non-existent<br \/>\nBy their very nature, then<br \/>\nYour words also lack reality<br \/>\nAnd can not refute true existence.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fnref:20\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">In his response,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0makes such statements as:<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fn:20\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">[20]<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Since there is nothing whatsoever to refute<br \/>\nI do not refute anything.<br \/>\nTherefore when you say that I refute<br \/>\nThat itself is incorrect.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Stanzas on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is an expansion of the section of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Root Verses<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0on \u2018Examining the Conditioned\u2019, which includes a discussion of how arising, dwelling and ceasing cannot be established. The proponents of true entities respond to this by pointing out that in many profound\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>sutras<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0taught by the Buddha, it is stated that conditioned phenomena are subject to arising, dwelling and ceasing. The\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>M\u0101dhyamika<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0replies that this is true only from the mistaken viewpoint of the conventional. This is the essence of the discussion found in the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Stanzas on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">So\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Refutation of Objections<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0and\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Seventy Stanzas on Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0are direct extensions from the body-like treatises.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Gorampa, as it was said earlier, identifies only five texts in the Collection of Reasoning. The omniscient\u00a0<u>Longchenpa<\/u>\u00a0identifies six texts, and his list accords with that of Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Among the New Translation schools, the Gelugpas claim that the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is the sixth text in the collection. Gorampa opposed this by pointing out that the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0is classified as advice, and therefore belongs to the Collection of Advice, not the Collection of Reasoning. In Candrak\u012brti\u2019s\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Clear Words<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, for instance, which I quoted earlier, it is referred to as \u2018the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Advice of the Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u2019.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">In any case, whether five or six texts are included, this is what is known as\u00a0<u>\u0100rya<\/u>\u00a0N\u0101g\u0101rjuna\u2019s Collection of Reasoning.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-2\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: OpenSans, Verdana, sans-serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Next Section<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">| Translated by\u00a0<a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/translators\/adam-pearcey\/\">Adam Pearcey<\/a>.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">Version: 2.3-20250407<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<hr \/>\n<ol>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:1\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">i.e., alchemy.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:1\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:2\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Ratn\u0101val\u012b<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">rin chen phreng ba<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>N\u0101g\u0101rjuna<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Buddhist Advice for Living and Liberation: N\u0101g\u0101rjuna&#8217;s Precious Garland<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, trans. Jeffrey Hopkins, Ithaca: Snow Lion, 1998.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:2\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:3\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Suh\u1e5bllekha<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">spring yig<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See Nagarjuna\u2019s\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Letter to a Friend with Commentary by Kyabje Kangyur Rinpoche<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, trans.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Padmakara<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0Translation Group, Ithaca: Snow Lion, 2006.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:3\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:4\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc (<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">rma bya byang chub brtson &#8216;grus<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, ?-1185).\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:4\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:5\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Gorampa Sonam Senge (<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">go rams pa bsod nams seng ge<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">), the famous Sakyapa scholar (1429-1489).\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:5\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:6\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Vigrahavy\u0101vartan\u012b-k\u0101rik\u0101<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">rtsod pa bzlog pa&#8217;i le&#8217;ur byas pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See _The Dialectical Method of N\u0101g\u0101rjuna, trans. K. Bhattacharya, Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1978.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:6\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:7\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u015a\u016bnyat\u0101-saptatik\u0101rik\u0101<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">stong pa nyid bdun bcu pa&#8217;i le&#8217;ur byas pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Nagarjuna\u2019s Seventy Stanzas: A Buddhist Psychology of Emptiness<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, David Ross Komito, Snow Lion, 1999.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:7\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:8\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Vaidalya-s\u016btra<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">zhib mo rnam par thag pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">).\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:8\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:9\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Vyavaharasiddhi<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">tha snyad grub pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">).\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:9\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<blockquote><p><a name=\"fn:10\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f62\u0f9f\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f64\u0f7a\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f60\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f62\u0f92\u0fb1\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f42\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f66\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa9\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f44\u0f7c\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f51\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f62\u0f92\u0fb1\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f66\u0fa4\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f60\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f55\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f62\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f56\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa3\u0f58\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f50\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f64\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb1\u0f0d \u0f0d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:10\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:11\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Prasannapad\u0101<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">tshig gsal<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Lucid Exposition of the\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Middle Way<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, trans. M. Sprung, London: Routledge &amp; Kegan Paul, 1979.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:11\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:12\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f50\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f45\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f9f\u0f7c\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f49\u0f72\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f51\u0f74\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f45\u0f74\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f44\u0f0d \u0f42\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa9\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa3\u0f58\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5f\u0fb3\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f40\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f50\u0f7c\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f42\u0fb1\u0f74\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f44\u0f0d \u0f56\u0f62\u0f92\u0fb1\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f51\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f66\u0fa1\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f5f\u0f56\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa3\u0f58\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f44\u0f0d \u0f66\u0f44\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f62\u0f92\u0fb1\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f66\u0f90\u0fb1\u0f44\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f5b\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f60\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f42\u0fb2\u0f7a\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f50\u0f7c\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f7a\u0f42\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f63\u0fa1\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb1\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f7a\u0f42\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f64\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f44\u0f0d \u0f42\u0f45\u0f72\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f45\u0f72\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f4f\u0f74\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f62\u0f92\u0fb1\u0f74\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f7c\u0f44\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f72\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa3\u0f58\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f55\u0fb1\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f62\u0f99\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f44\u0f0d\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f66\u0fa1\u0f58\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f4f\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb3\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f46\u0f7a\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f63\u0fa1\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa3\u0f58\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f42\u0f74\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb1\u0f0b\u0f55\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f66\u0f9f\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0d \u0f0d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:12\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:13\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Patsab Nyima Drakpa (<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">pa tshab nyi ma grags pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, 1055-1145?).\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:13\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:14\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">There so-called \u2018Four Sons of Patsab\u2019 are referred to in a verse of Taktsang\u00a0<u>Lotsawa<\/u>:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">As regards the Great Middle Way, the supreme tradition of\u00a0<u>Nagarjuna<\/u>,<br \/>\nThe excellent clarifications made by Candra[k\u012brti], translated by Nyima [Drak],<br \/>\nCame down to the four sons\u2026.<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">There are different ways of listing them. According to one, they were: (1) Gangpa She\u2019u, who was learned in the words, (2) Tsangpa Dregur (<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f59\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f56\u0fb2\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f92\u0f74\u0f62\u0f0d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">or\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f59\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f56\u0fb2\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f90\u0f74\u0f62\u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">), who was learned in the meaning, (3) Mabja Changchub Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc, who was learned in both words and meaning, and (4) Shangthang Sakpa Yeshe Jungne, who was learned in neither words nor meaning. Shakya Chokden names Tsangpa Sarb\u00f6 (<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f59\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f66\u0fa6\u0f7c\u0f66\u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">) as the son who was learned in the words and Daryulwa Rinchen Drak as the son learned in the meaning. See Tashi Tsering,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Madhyamakavatara of Acarya Candrakirti<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Sarnath: Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies, 2005, p. 48 and Shakya Chokden,\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Three Texts on Madhyamaka<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, trans. Komarovski Iaroslav, Dharamsala: Library of Tibetan Works and Archives, 2002. p. 23.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:14\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:15\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">gsang sngags lung gi bang mdzod<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f66\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f94\u0f42\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f74\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f5b\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">)\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:15\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:16\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">M\u016blamadhyamakavrittyakutobhaya<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f51\u0f56\u0f74\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f0b\u0f62\u0fa9\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f60\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f42\u0fb2\u0f7a\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f47\u0f72\u0f42\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">)\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:16\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:17\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Catu\u1e25\u015bataka<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0(<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">bzhi brgya pa<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">). See Sonam, R. (trans.)\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Yogic Deeds of\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><u>Bodhisattvas<\/u><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Gyel-tsap on \u0100ryadeva\u2019s Four Hundred<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/em><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">, Snow Lion, 1994.\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:17\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:18\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">This is also the assertion of Khenpo Namdrol\u2019s teacher, Khenpo Ts\u00f6ndr\u00fc. See\u00a0<a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-tsondru\/prajnaparamita-preliminaries\">Preliminaries to the Explanation of the Praj\u00f1\u0101p\u0101ramit\u0101<\/a>\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:18\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<blockquote><p><a name=\"fn:19\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f42\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f4f\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f44\u0f7c\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f50\u0f58\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f45\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f62\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f40\u0f74\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f63\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f41\u0fb1\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f59\u0f72\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f62\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f62\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5e\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f56\u0f5f\u0fb3\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f74\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f66\u0f7c\u0f0d \u0f0d\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/span><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1#fnref:19\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">\u00a0&#x21a9;<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/a><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<\/li>\n<li>\n<p align=\"left\"><a name=\"fn:20\"><\/a> <span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\">Verse 64:<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n<blockquote><p><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f51\u0f42\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb1\u0f0b\u0f45\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f53\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f45\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f61\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f72\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f42\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f42\u0f7c\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f51\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f55\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f62\u0f0b\u0f60\u0f42\u0f7c\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f54\u0f0b\u0f56\u0fb1\u0f7a\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f7c\u0f0b\u0f5e\u0f7a\u0f66\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, Georgia, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: large;\"><br \/>\n<\/span><\/span><\/span><span style=\"font-family: Arial Unicode MS;\"><span lang=\"hi-IN\"><span style=\"font-family: DDCUchen;\"><span style=\"font-size: small;\">\u0f61\u0f44\u0f0b\u0f51\u0f42\u0f0b\u0f58\u0f72\u0f53\u0f0b\u0f4f\u0f7a\u0f0b\u0f41\u0fb1\u0f7c\u0f51\u0f0b\u0f40\u0fb1\u0f72\u0f66\u0f0b\u0f66\u0fa8\u0fb2\u0f66\u0f0d \u0f0d<\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p align=\"left\"><span style=\"color: #444444;\"><span style=\"font-family: Spectral, serif;\"><span style=\"font-size: medium;\"><span style=\"color: #8d281e;\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1\">https:\/\/www.lotsawahouse.org\/tibetan-masters\/khenpo-namdrol-tsering\/madhyamakavatara-1<\/a> <\/span><\/span><\/span><\/span><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Commentary on the Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra\u2014Part 1\u2014Collection of Reasoning by\u00a0Khenchen Namdrol Tsering In this teaching, translated from an audio recording, Khenchen Namdrol Tsering explains the background to Candrak\u012brti&#8217;s classic work by discussing the texts of the &#8216;collection (or corpus) of reasoning&#8217; (rigs tshogs) attributed to N\u0101g\u0101rjuna, the great philosopher and founder of the Madhyamaka tradition. Madhyamak\u0101vat\u0101ra: Collection <a href=\"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/?p=12523\">Continue reading &#8594;<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[111,99,160,141],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12523"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=12523"}],"version-history":[{"count":2,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12523\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":12625,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/12523\/revisions\/12625"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=12523"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=12523"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sangye.it\/altro\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=12523"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}