His Holiness the Dalai Lama addressing representatives of Tibet Support Groups at his residence in Dharamsala, HP, India on November 4, 2019. Photo by Ven Tenzin Jamphel
November 4, 2019. Thekchen Chöling, Dharamsala, India – When 180 representatives of Tibet Support Groups from 42 countries met with His Holiness the Dalai Lama this morning, he mentioned having been told that Chinese documents from the Tang dynasty refer to Tibet, China and Mongolia as independent states. He added that there are no historical references in such documents to Tibet being part of China. He remarked how impressed has been by the spirit of the European Union and can envisage Tibet’s being part of a such a union with China. He said that to insist on Tibetan independence would entail only what’s called Outer Tibet, which would involve just two million Tibetans. If, on the other hand, all the various Tibetan regions could be brought together, since the Chinese constitution recognises the autonomy of such regions and their right to preserve their Tibetan culture, 6-7 million Tibetans would be involved.
“Tibet has a long history with a rich culture rooted in a profound knowledge of Buddhism,” His Holiness observed. “Indeed, Tibetans have maintained what is probably the most extensive presentation of the Buddha’s teachings. When professors in Chinese universities read books we have published here, that compile scientific and philosophical materials from the Kangyur and Tengyur, they are reported to have acknowledged the authentic origin of Tibetan Buddhism in the Nalanda Tradition and its scientific character. This is a source of confidence for us.
“For more than 70 years the spirit of the people in Tibet has been undaunted. Their determination will continue because of their pride in the value of our rich culture. I have been told that, in the face of such determination, some members of the Chinese leadership have begun to admit that their policy has been misplaced and that there is a need for a more realistic approach. Voices of concern from other parts of the world are helpful at such a juncture. On behalf of the six million Tibetans I’d like to thank you for your kindness and support.”
As His Holiness walked from his residence to the Tsuglagkhang, the Main Tibetan Temple, the sun shone, the sky was a clear blue and a scattering of snow was visible on the peaks towering in the background. He made his way briskly through the yard, waving to members of the public as he went. More than 6000 people had gathered to listen to him, of whom more than 2000 had come from 60 countries around the world. Principal among them were people from South Korea, who filled the temple.
The moment His Holiness had taken his seat on the throne Thai monks sitting before it recited the Mangala Sutta in Pali. They were replaced by Korean monks who chanted the ‘Heart Sutra’ in Korean to the beat of a wooden gong.
“You Koreans have come again to listen to teachings and I thought we could look at the ‘Heart Sutra’, which is both simple and difficult,” His Holiness disclosed. “Today, since we have three days, I’ll give an introduction to the teachings and I’ll see if we can begin the ‘Heart Sutra’. Tomorrow, I’ll also explain the ‘Three Principal Aspects of the Path’, which is short and has been translated into Korean.
“Here in the 21st century we’ve made great material progress, so we might ask ourselves what is the benefit of religion today? There are some traditions whose message of love and compassion is based on their belief in a compassionate creator God. Since followers of such traditions believe that all beings are creations of such a god, making them brothers and sisters, you might ask how they could fight and kill each other?
“In India, there are traditions, like some of the Samkhya, Jains and Buddhists, who don’t assert a creator. Instead, they consider the pain and pleasure we experience to be a consequence of our own actions. Therefore, they teach that what happens to us is in our hands. Some recognise the existence of a self separate from our body and mind. They say that it is this self that goes on from life to life. Buddhists, however, declare that it is the continuity of subtle consciousness that goes on from life to life.
“We may experience pain and pleasure physically, but the feelings such episodes entail take place in the mind. Despite this, there are people who have little appreciation of the function of the mind. In ancient Indian tradition, mind was explained in detail. Although records of this are found in religious texts, such knowledge need not be restricted to the religious sphere. It can be examined in an academic, secular context.
“If you want to avoid suffering, you should seek out its causes and examine whether they can be eliminated. Similarly, once you recognise the causes of happiness you should cultivate them, much as we plant seeds in the earth and nurture them with water and manure until they bear fruit.
“The Buddha advised his followers not to accept what he taught blindly, but to examine and test it. He said if it is not corroborated by reason, don’t accept it, but look again. Because of Buddhism’s use of logic and its profound philosophical approach, Buddhist students can have constructive conversations with modern scientists. Many of them appreciate the Buddhist notion of dependent arising. Others are struck by Buddhist understanding of the workings of mind and the emotions.”
His Holiness discussed the mind’s different levels of subtlety. He observed that when we fall asleep and dream a subtler consciousness manifests that is not dominated by sensory experience. He noted that it is mental afflictions that disturb our peace of mind. Due to anger and attachment we bring suffering on ourselves and others. Since peace of mind entails an end to mental restlessness it is worth learning about different states of mind and discovering antidotes to mental afflictions like attachment and anger.
Despite technological advancement, we can only transform our minds by engaging with mind. This can be done in an entirely secular way. India’s precious traditions of non-violence and compassion— ‘ahimsa’ and ‘karuna’—remain relevant today. Compassion brings peace of mind. Anger and attachment bring fear and suspicion. It’s natural for us to respond with compassion because we are social animals.
“In teaching about selflessness, the Buddha demonstrated that nothing exists independently from its own side. When you hold yourself dear, it intensifies inappropriate thinking. We not only hold onto the way things appear, we hold onto the qualities of goodness or beauty in those objects. However, the Middle Way School declares that nothing exists independently, despite appearing to do so, and that things have no objective existence. This corresponds to the thought that underlies quantum physics’ appraisal of phenomena.
“When Nagarjuna writes in his ‘Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way’,
Through the elimination of karma and afflictive emotions there is liberation;
Karma and mental afflictions come from conceptual constructs;
These come about from mental fabrication;
Fabrication ceases through emptiness.
he means that ignorance is ended when you understand emptiness. If the profound knowledge of ancient India could be combined with modern education it could be very helpful. While the practice of altruism counters self-centredness, the idea that things don’t exist intrinsically as they appear to counters our misconception that thing inherently exist. Such a combination can bring about a powerful transformation.”
His Holiness took up the text of the ‘Heart Sutra’. He explained that the Buddha gave three rounds of teaching, referred to as turnings of the wheel of dharma. The Pali tradition is based on the first round and includes the three scriptural collections, as well as the strict observance of Vinaya—monastic discipline.
In his second round of teachings, at Rajgir, the Buddha explained the perfection of wisdom. Texts recording these teachings are extensive, medium and short in length. The shortest being the syllable ‘ah’, which is a term of negation. The ‘Heart Sutra’ is also known as the perfection of wisdom in 25 stanzas. There are several Indian commentaries to it in the Tengyur such as Jnanamitra’s ‘Essence of the Exalted Perfection of Wisdom’.
His Holiness clarified that the term ‘exalted’ here refers to the status of someone who has attained the path of seeing. He added that such attainment is achieved through learning, reflection and meditation. Such practice involves cultivating a calmly abiding mind and insight into reality—shamatha and vipashyana.
“We also talk about the practice of method and wisdom,” he remarked. “Method involves cultivating the awakening mind of bodhichitta, the intention to reach Buddhahood to be able to help others. The form dimension of Buddhahood is achieved through the accumulation of merit. The dimension of truth is achieved through the wisdom understanding ultimate reality.
“The first round of the Buddha’s teachings laid the foundation. The second, the explanation of the perfection of wisdom, to which the Nalanda Tradition pays special attention, leads to making progress on the spiritual path. The third round revealed the subtlest consciousness, the mind of clear light.
“Soon after his enlightenment the Buddha is said to have expressed these thoughts—’Profound and peaceful, free from elaboration, uncompounded clear light, I have found a nectar-like Dharma. Yet if I were to teach it, there is no-one who would understand what I said; therefore, I shall remain silent here in the forest.’ We can understand this verse as anticipating the teachings he would eventually give. ‘Profound and peaceful’ refers to the first round of his teachings; ‘free from complexity’ refers to content of the second round, while ‘uncompounded luminosity’ refers to the third round.”
His Holiness explained the first lines of the ‘Heart Sutra’, ‘Thus have I heard at one time… the Blessed One had entered into meditative absorption on the varieties of phenomena called the appearance of the profound.’ The word appearance refers to conventional existence, while profound indicates ultimate existence. Although things are empty of intrinsic, independent existence, they still have a conventional appearance. This, His Holiness suggested, also alludes to dependent arising.
When the bodhisattva saw ‘that even the five aggregates are empty of intrinsic existence’, it revealed the selflessness not just of persons, but of phenomena too.
His Holiness announced that he would stop there for today and will resume tomorrow. He told the congregation that Samdhong Rinpoché would conduct a review of the day’s instruction and urged them not to hold back from asking him questions. https://www.dalailama.com/news/2019/first-day-of-heart-sutra-teaching-at-the-request-of-koreans
